I have to say I'm puzzled by the negativity. LOS already cleared up the issue with multiple clubs. The problems you're facing is not with the WHS. But I also have to ask why those scores from France weren't also posted to your CONGU handicap in the first place (and vice versa)?
Also, WalkerCup, how is the higher cap shooting a lower net score any different from CONGU? A net 60 would usually be 10-12 strokes below handicap, so 46-48 points. A 12 would've been cut some 2.5-3 strokes (I can't recall the cut off points for different categories anymore), in the WHS the player would be cut by close to 4 strokes, probably 1.5-2 strokes because of the great differential alone and another 2 strokes for the exceptional score.
And why shouldn't the 30 handicap win if he/she happened to have an even better day? After all handicapped events aren't about who is the best golfer, it's about who happens to have the best day. And if you imply cheating, that's a committee problem, not a WHS one, WHS provide all the tools to deal with it.
Also, pros have handicaps in the WHS unlike in the old EGA and CONGU systems (unless England opted out of that one).
Oh, one more thing, nothing changed in what are acceptable scores in the U.S. and in Europe so the match play argument is moot. (Except for Ireland.)
Also, WalkerCup, how is the higher cap shooting a lower net score any different from CONGU? A net 60 would usually be 10-12 strokes below handicap, so 46-48 points. A 12 would've been cut some 2.5-3 strokes (I can't recall the cut off points for different categories anymore), in the WHS the player would be cut by close to 4 strokes, probably 1.5-2 strokes because of the great differential alone and another 2 strokes for the exceptional score.
And why shouldn't the 30 handicap win if he/she happened to have an even better day? After all handicapped events aren't about who is the best golfer, it's about who happens to have the best day. And if you imply cheating, that's a committee problem, not a WHS one, WHS provide all the tools to deal with it.
Also, pros have handicaps in the WHS unlike in the old EGA and CONGU systems (unless England opted out of that one).
Oh, one more thing, nothing changed in what are acceptable scores in the U.S. and in Europe so the match play argument is moot. (Except for Ireland.)